The Best Old Fashioned Cookie Press For You!

Do you remember the days of making cookies with your grandmother using her old-fashioned cookie press? Well, if you’re looking to relive those memories and make some delicious cookies, you’re in luck. In this article, we’ll be discussing the best old-fashioned cookie press and why it’s the perfect tool for making all of your favorite cookies. We’ll also provide some tips on how to get the best results. So if you’re ready to make some delicious cookies, let’s get started.

1OXO Good Grips 14-Piece Cookie Press Set…
2Fante’s Easy Cookie Press, The Italian Market Original Since 1906…
3Wilton Preferred Press Cookie Press, 13-Piece…
4Cuisinart WMR-CA Round Classic Waffle Maker (Renewed)…
5Hutzler Easy Action Cookie Press and Food Decorator, one size, Wh…

OXO Good Grips 14-Piece Cookie Press Set

What We Think About This

  • Comes apart for easy filling and cleaning
  • Creates consistent cookies with the press of a lever
  • Non-slip base keeps Cookie Press steady
  • Clear body shows how much dough is left
  • Large, non-slip lever is comfortable for repetitive use
  • Convenient case for storing disks
  • Durable, stainless steel disks in 12 classic and custom designs

Fante’s Easy Cookie Press, the Italian Market Original Since 1906

What We Think About This

  • 5 traditional shapes slide into place for easy cookies and other treats; easier than using cookie cutters; no more rolling dough or sticky mess
  • Disassembles for easy cleaning; hand wash in warm, soapy water and dry thoroughly; includes complete instructions and Fante’s family recipe
  • Fantes Nana Anna’s Cookie Press extrudes firm dough into many creative shapes for authentic Italian cookies, cheese straws, and more
  • Easy to load and use; simply unscrew top cover to open and fill with dough, slide plate to the desired shape, and turn handle
  • Each turn of the handle advances the dough effortlessly with a firm, gentle pressure for consistent cookie results, every time

Wilton Preferred Press Cookie Press, 13-Piece

What We Think About This

  • QUICK CLEANUP: Hand wash the Wilton cookie press in warm, soapy water; rinse and dry thoroughly
  • READY, SET, BAKE: Press to impress with this unique cookie tool. The Wilton Preferred Press Cookie Press makes it easy to make and bake beautiful spritz cookies with minimal effort
  • PERFORMANCE: The Wilton press has an ergonomic hourglass shape so it’s easy to hold, a see-through design so you know when to refill it with dough and a soft-grip trigger so you can press out dozens of cookies quickly
  • INCLUDES: 12 different shaped discs and the Preferred Press Cookie Press, cookie press dimensions: 8.75 x 11 x 2.6 inches
  • BAKEWARE FOR EVERY DAY AND EVERY OCCASION: This Wilton Cookie Press comes with 12 Fit Right discs in these shapes: Christmas tree, wreath, snowman, pumpkin, turkey, dots, doily, pinwheel, heart, starburst, and biscuit

Cuisinart WMR-CA Round Classic Waffle Maker (Renewed)

What We Think About This

  • Browning control with five temperature settings adjusts to bake light-to-deep-golden-color waffles
  • Bakes one large traditional-style waffle
  • Limited 3-year warranty
  • Nonstick baking plates
  • 90 Day Manufacturer Warranty
  • Brushed Stainless Steel housing
  • Five-setting browning control
  • Ready to Bake” and “Ready to Eat” indicator lights for easy operation

Hutzler Easy Action Cookie Press and Food Decorator, One Size, Wh

What We Think About This

  • Move at your own pace without any squeezing or twisting
  • Makes cookies, macaroons, pasta and cheese straws
  • Turns into a food decorator so you can decorate cakes and cookies, make deviled eggs, twice baked potatoes, etc.
  • This is the only cookie press that makes 2-toned cookies (with a colored center)
  • It takes just 2 easy steps to get a perfectly-shaped cookie: lift handle & click down

How To Choose Your Old Fashioned Cookie Press

Use our buying guide before you purchase Old Fashioned Cookie Press. Some features are necessary, while others may not be as important to you.:

Quality of the Unit

The product should be high-quality, durable, and last for more than one year. The best way to assess the quality is by reading reviews from other customers who have purchased and used the product.

Is the Unit Worth the Price Tag?

Price is not the only factor to consider while buying a product, but it’s an important one. You should compare how much you’re willing to spend on the item with what other sellers are offering similar products for. Keep in mind that cheaper isn’t always better – quality should also be taken into consideration.

If the price difference is significant, choose the more expensive option as it is likely to be of better quality and last longer than its cheaper counterparts.


Before you buy a product, always double-check that the model you want includes all of the features you desire! If you’re unsure about any of them, read reviews from customers who have used those specific features. This way, you can get an idea of whether or not they would be useful to YOU.


There are a lot of risks involved while buying products online. Sometimes, the product doesn’t reach you, or it comes in damaged condition. So make sure that the seller offers a guarantee on the product.

Customer Support

Last but not the least, make sure that customer support is available for you in case of any issues or queries regarding your purchased product. If there is no help desk support, then you can always go to forums and review sites to find answers to any doubts.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the best type of dough to use with an old fashioned cookie press?

The best type of dough to use with an old fashioned cookie press is a firm, yet pliable, sugar cookie dough. This type of dough will hold its shape under the pressure of the cookie press and will still be soft and flavorful when baked.

2. How do you clean and store an old fashioned cookie press?

To clean and store an old fashioned cookie press, first disassemble the press, removing the plunger and any metal or plastic pieces. Wash all parts with warm, soapy water and a soft cloth or sponge. Rinse with clean water and dry thoroughly. Place all the parts back together, making sure the plunger is firmly in place. Wrap the cookie press in a clean towel and store in a dry place.

3. What types of decorations can you make with an old fashioned cookie press?

– Decorations that can be made with an old fashioned cookie press include star-shaped cookies, snowflake cookies, flower cookies, heart-shaped cookies, and other intricate designs.

4. Are there any tips for getting the perfect cookie shape with an old fashioned cookie press?

1. Make sure the dough is not too soft or too hard – it should be the perfect consistency for pressing. 2. Chill the dough for at least 30 minutes before pressing, as this will help it hold its shape. 3. Grease the cookie press lightly with cooking spray or butter to prevent sticking. 4. Experiment with different amounts of pressure when pressing out the cookies. 5. If the dough is too soft or too hard, add a little more flour or butter to adjust the consistency. 6. Make sure the cookies are spaced out evenly on the baking sheet. 7. Bake the cookies at the right temperature and time. 8. Let the cookies cool completely before removing them from the baking sheet.

5. How do you remove stuck dough from an old fashioned cookie press?

To remove stuck dough from an old fashioned cookie press, first try gently tapping or shaking the cookie press. If that does not work, try using a butter knife or other thin utensil to carefully pry the dough away from the press. If the dough is still stuck, try submerging the press in hot water to soften the dough before attempting to pry it away.

Leave a Comment